Market research, competitor analysis, customer profiles, niches, gaps, opportunities.
Useful things. But perhaps not the best place to begin.
There is a tendency to treat starting a business like a search problem. Scan the market until you find some neglected corner. Narrow the audience, isolate a pain point, estimate willingness to pay. The less competition, the more promising it looks.
Taken far enough, you can end up in a domain you know nothing about, solving a problem you couldn’t care less about.
The tools aren’t the problem. The order is.
Market research is good at testing an idea. It is less obvious that it should be generating the idea in the first place.
Most things worth making already have alternatives. The domains we care about tend to be crowded precisely because other people care about them too. Competition can make a business harder, but its absence isn’t automatically a gift. Sometimes nobody is there because nobody wants what would be there.
So perhaps finding the empty corner is the wrong question.
Start closer to yourself.
What do you wish existed? What do you already use but find irritating? What have you cobbled together because nothing available quite does the job? What existing product do you keep wishing someone would make differently?
Make that.
Not because being your own customer guarantees anything. You can make something perfect for yourself and discover that you are an audience of one.
But at least the problem is real.
You understand it from the inside. You know what bothers you, what compromises you’ve accepted, and what would make the thing meaningfully better. You don’t have to manufacture enthusiasm for a promising niche.
Then make it work for you.
Only after that does reality get a vote.
Show it to other people. See whether they understand why it exists without needing a long explanation. See whether they return to it. See whether they care enough to pay, switch, recommend it, or change whatever they were doing before.
This is where the market research, competitor analysis, pricing and distribution come back in. They still matter. A personal obsession isn’t a business model.
But now they are testing something that began with an actual reason to exist rather than trying to invent one.
There is another advantage too.
If it works, you get to spend your time tending something you genuinely wanted in the world.
If it doesn’t, you still made something you wanted.
That seems like a better starting position than finding a theoretically attractive market and hoping you eventually learn to care about it.
Make something for yourself first.
Then find out whether anyone else wants it too.
Make something for yourself
The business plan can tell you whether the idea survives contact with reality. It shouldn't have to invent the reason you care about it.
Essay continues on the right →
← all essays